While a player with Philadelphia connections faced the Flyers for the first time, a former Flyers great added to his long legacy and was paid a compliment by a Hall of Famer.
Former captain Claude Giroux opened the scoring against his former club in Thursday's game, which ended with a 6-5 Flyers win after a thrilling comeback, but it was the comments made by longtime Philadelphia sportswriter, radio personality, and Flyers broadcaster Al Morganti in between periods that caused a bit of a stir.
Morganti went out of his way to declare that Claude Giroux is a Hall of Famer in waiting. Now, while Morganti clearly has built up an affinity for the Flyers over the years, he's far from a homer and is also a Hockey Hall of Famer himself, having been inducted alongside former Flyer and broadcast legend Bill Clement.
Now his words have sparked a fascinating debate that gets more complex with each passing season. Is Claude Giroux actually a Hall of Famer, or is he a very good player who will jump out to some on a point list and fall just short of enshrinement?
The Case For
You could make a baseball-style argument for Giroux. He's played 1368 NHL games so far and has rarely missed a game, despite being on the smaller side for a forward. He's also sitting at 1178 points, 1 behind Hall of Famer Sergei Fedorov, in 59th place for now. However, Fedorov will fall within the month, with Rod Brind'Amour at 1184 and Patrick Marleau at 1194 points, also likely to be passed. After the 1200-point barrier, you've got Dino Ciccarelli at 1200, Vincent Damphousse at 1205, Bernie Nichols at 1209, and Bobby Clarke at 1210, all in range. Outside of Damphousse and Nichols, everyone in this range is in the Hall of Fame or will be at some point. His playoff scoring (86 points in 105 games) isn't the highest number but is still consistent.
All of this was done without a very strong supporting cast. When he played with Hall of Famers like Jaromir Jagr or Chris Pronger, it was for a short time. He spent the rest of his career elevating players like Scott Harnell, Jakub Vorachek, and Wayne Simmonds into scoring threats.
Grioux also has marks on other lists, like the all-time assists marker at #38 with 794 (just 3 behind Jari Kurri and 18 behind Pierre Turgeon) and is #53rd on the all-time power play points mark with 435, just three points shy of jumping into the top 50, passing Jarome Iginla and Daniel Alfredsson on the way. He's also 8th all time in faceoffs won, which is one of the extra stats that can help build a case.
His consistency has made him one of the most effective and efficient scorers in NHL history. He's all over Hall of Fame territory. Being this good for this long should get a player in. It might for Claude.
The Case Against
In a league where scoring has increased and was practically mandated by the league, so as point totals swell, you may see more players pass the 1100 and 1200 point markers and not get in. Especially a player like Grioux, who has no individual awards to speak of.
He has 3 top 5 finishes in Hart Trophy voting, but outside of that, he's never come close to winning anything, and the sport's ultimate trophy, the Stanley Cup, has also eluded him. Team success shouldn't overly factor in, but it does have a heavy influence.
It wouldn't exactly be a problem if Giroux was, at one point, the best player in the world, but outside of Peter Laviolette, Giroux really was never that guy. He was and still is immensely talented but never had the greatest individual skill in any area; he was just really good at everything.
Where he ends up might just be decided by how high he can push his overall points total. With only a one-year deal and being 39 by season's end, Giroux might not want to continue beyond this year, and then we'll have to wait a few more years to see what the voters think.
